SBOE holds first meeting of 2023, debates private school vouchers

Texas Legislature TEA | Commissioner | SBOE Privatization | Vouchers Deregulation | Charter Schools
Date Posted: 2/03/2023 | Author: Mark Wiggins
The State Board of Education (SBOE) met Feb. 2-3, 2023, in Austin. Six newly elected members joined the board at its first meeting of 2023. Melissa Ortega (D-El Paso), LJ Francis (R-Corpus Christi), Staci Childs (D-Houston), Julie Pickren (R-Pearland), Evelyn Brooks (R-Frisco), and Aaron Kinsey (R-Midland) participated in their first meeting since their election this past November.

Addressing the board in person for the first time, Gov. Greg Abbott (R) swore in the new and returning board members Friday after a brief speech in which he claimed schools were not doing an adequate job educating students. Abbott, who has recently accused public schools of “indoctrination,” made no mention of his campaign promise to pass a voucher bill this session that would divert taxpayer dollars away from local public schools to subsidize private and for-profit schools, most of which are located in the state’s major metropolitan areas.
The governor’s unusual appearance coincided with the board’s walking back its public rejection of vouchers during its prior meeting. A bipartisan majority of members voted 11-2 in November to include opposition to all forms of vouchers as one of the SBOE’s legislative priorities for 2023.
The newly composed board voted 8-5 along party lines Thursday to remove the reference to vouchers and take no official position on the subject. Member Brooks was not present, and Chairman Keven Ellis (R-Lufkin) did not vote, per his usual practice as board chair.
The board also voted 9-4 to instruct the Texas Education Agency (TEA) to initiate rulemaking to amend the no-contact period for charter school applicants. Current rules include a blackout period in which charter school applicants may not contact and lobby board members who will decide their approval.
As we previously reported, charter school backers spent unprecedented sums to elect charter-friendly SBOE members during the 2022 election cycle. The vote to explore loosening oversight of charter applicants came on the first meeting with these new candidates on the board.

This week’s SBOE meetings were originally scheduled to begin Tuesday but were compressed to Thursday and Friday due to the winter storm. As part of standard reorganizing following an election, SBOE members elected Pam Little (R-Fairview) as board vice-chair and Pat Hardy (R-Fort Worth) as secretary. Ellis continues to serve out his term as Gov. Abbott’s appointed chairman of the new board.
Audrey Young (R-Apple Springs) will chair the SBOE Committee on Instruction, which includes Brooks, Aicha Davis (D-Dallas), Little, and Ortega.
Tom Maynard (R-Florence) will continue to chair the Committee on School Finance/Permanent School Fund, which includes Ellis, Hardy, Kinsey, and Marisa Perez-Diaz (D-Converse).
Will Hickman (R-Houston) will chair the Committee on School Initiatives, which includes Childs, Francis, Rebecca Bell-Metereau (D-San Marcos), and Pickren.
CONVERSATION
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

05/28/2025
Deadlines and dying bills and the promise of sine die
While many Texans were enjoying a long weekend, the Texas Legislature continued to work ahead of this week's end-of-session deadlines.

05/23/2025
Teach the Vote’s Week in Review: May 23, 2025
House and Senate leadership move forward with a major school finance deal in CSHB 2. Plus, find out what’s happening at the federal level with charter schools, budget reconciliation, and the Department of Education.

05/23/2025
Federal Roundup: Supreme Court decision on charter schools, budget reconciliation update, and more
A deadlocked Supreme Court blocked the State of Oklahoma from using taxpayer dollars to run a religious charter school.
As part of state expenditures, charter schools should be monitored and audited for compliance with SBOE requirements, and not given special treatment in any regard.