ATPE responds to Texas lawmaker’s demand that school districts review hundreds of books and materials for content regarding race or sex
Texas Legislature Curriculum | Instruction TEA | Commissioner | SBOE
Date Posted: 10/26/2021
The Association of Texas Professional Educators (ATPE) responded Tuesday to a politically motivated book inquiry demanded by state Rep. Matt Krause (R-Fort Worth), who has announced his intent to run for statewide office in 2022.
Krause, who chairs the House Committee on General Investigating, sent a letter Monday, Oct. 25, 2021, addressed to the Texas Education Agency (TEA) and “selected superintendents” announcing an inquiry on behalf of his committee into “school district content.” The letter demands that the districts, which are unnamed, review a 16-page list of hundreds of books Krause has deemed concerning.
The list includes more than 750 books covering a range of topics and dating back to 1969. Each district is asked to report the number of copies it possesses of each book on the list, identify the location of each book on the list, including school library and classroom collections, and disclose the amount of funds spent to acquire each copy.
Krause is also asking each district to provide the same information for “any other books or content” not necessarily on the list that contain the topics of “human sexuality, sexually transmitted diseases, or human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) or acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS), sexually explicit images, graphic presentations of sexual behavior that is in violation of the law, or contain material that might make students feel discomfort, guilt, anguish, or any other form of psychological distress because of their race or sex or convey that a student, by virtue of their race or sex, is inherently racist, sexist, or oppressive, whether consciously or unconsciously.”
The lawmaker’s inquiry echoes themes debated extensively this year over such bills as House Bill 3979 enacted in the regular session and Senate Bill 3 enacted in the second special session. According to the authors of the legislation, both laws seek to ban schools from teaching concepts that have been associated with “critical race theory.” HB 3979 prohibits educators from including in social studies course requirements “the concept that… an individual should feel discomfort, guilt, anguish, or any other form of psychological distress on account of the individual's race or sex.” Rep. Krause’s letter mirrors that same language, although ATPE notes that there is nothing in HB 3979 requiring school districts to review books that might contain references to similar concepts.
ATPE issued a press statement Tuesday in response to reporters’ inquiries about the overreaching book review. ATPE Executive Director Shannon Holmes called Krause’s probe a “Frankenstein monster, stitching together different and unrelated issues and requirements” and “driven by culture wars, not common sense.”
Rep. Krause is an attorney who was first elected to the Texas House in 2012. He recently announced his intent to run for Texas Attorney General, challenging incumbent Ken Paxton in the 2022 Republican primary election.
“This is yet another attempt by a legislator eyeing higher office to shore up street cred with the political base by dividing parents and educators in the public education community,” said Holmes. “Moreover, it’s a waste of taxpayer resources for school districts, which are already grappling with big issues, including staffing shortages and student learning losses, due to pandemic-related challenges and new laws enacted by the Legislature this year. We hear every day from teachers who are losing their planning time to cover classes because there are too few substitutes. Administrators are struggling to staff both in-person and online classrooms, plus tutoring sessions now mandated for many students. Districts do not have the added bandwidth to meet this onerous and unnecessary request, and it will be student instruction that suffers.”
The State Board of Education (SBOE) has the sole authority to set curriculum standards and evaluate instructional materials. Krause attempted to justify his inquiry under statute granting the general investigative committees of legislature the authority to initiate inquiries concerning “matter the committee considers necessary for the information of the legislature or for the welfare and protection of state citizens.”
The letter echoes a trend over the past legislative session of steering controversial education policy decisions away from the formal policymaking bodies – the SBOE, House Public Education Committee, and Senate Education Committee – where educators can provide input. Krause has not scheduled a public hearing on the topic he is pursuing, purportedly on behalf of his committee. The letter calls for TEA and districts to provide a response by November 12, 2021.
Related: Read media reporting about the Krause inquiry and ATPE's response (subscriptions may be required for access):
- Washington Post: Texas GOP lawmaker launches investigation of books on race and sexuality used in school districts, published 10/27/21
- Ft. Worth Star-Telegram: Fort Worth lawmaker targets 849 books in school libraries. Their topics? Sex, race, LGBTQ, published 10/26/21
- Dallas Morning News: Books about race, sexuality spark investigation into Texas schools by a House committee, published 10/26/21
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU
Teach the Vote’s Week in Review: June 2, 2023
The HB 100 voucher scheme dies at the end of regular session, plus a special session and the TEA takeover of Houston ISD begin.
From The Texas Tribune: Tension over property taxes produces rare public clash between Dan Patrick, Greg Abbott
Always happy to castigate the Texas House, Patrick breaks form to criticize the governor as misinformed and unsympathetic toward homeowners.
School Finance, Retirement | TRS | Social Security, Texas Legislature, Privatization | Vouchers, Educator Compensation | Benefits
Voucher dies as final weekend of 88th Legislature brings conflict between House and Senate
HB 100 was a casualty of a breakdown in communications between the House and Senate as the regular session drew to a close.