5th Circuit Court denies rehearing in publishers’ Texas library book lawsuit

Date Posted: 4/18/2024 | Author: Mark Wiggins
The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals issued an en banc decision Monday affirming its decision to overturn a law that would have required book publishers to develop a rating system based on sexual content.
The full court voted 9-8 to deny rehearing a lawsuit filed by book publishers against House Bill (HB) 900 by Rep. Jared Patterson (R–Frisco), which the Texas Legislature passed in 2023.
Publishers argued that the portion of the law requiring the rating system was an unconstitutional restriction on speech.
The court sided with publishers and struck down the ratings requirement while leaving intact the portion of the law that required the Texas State Library and Archives Commission (TSLAC) to promulgate school library collection development standards.
Patterson responded to the decision by urging Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) to immediately appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The State Board of Education (SBOE) gave final approval to the TSLAC library standards under HB 900 in December. The rules apply to all school and classroom libraries in the public school system.
CONVERSATION
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

08/28/2025
Senate approves HB 8, STAAR replacement bill
HB 8 promises additional transparency and quicker results, but it does not reduce the overall footprint of high-stakes testing in Texas public schools.

08/27/2025
From The Texas Tribune: House Democrats’ frustration with STAAR bill highlights divide over how new test should look
Democrats say recent changes to the bill give too much power to the TEA and fall short of meaningfully easing the pressures of standardized testing.

08/26/2025
House passes HB 8, its assessment and accountability bill
Five amendments were adopted before House members advanced the bill to the Senate on an 82-56 vote.