Senate committee advances House A-F bill with Senate language

Date Posted: 5/18/2017
The Senate Education Committee met today to hear a list of House bills that included HB 22, Chairman Dan Huberty’s (R-Humble) bill to fix issues that arose from the A-F campus rating system passed last legislative session. As it was heard in the Senate committee today, the bill was amended by Senate Education Chairman Larry Taylor (R-Friendswood) to substitute the language of his own A-F accountability bill, SB 2051. ATPE testified on the legislation as we did previously when SB 2051 was heard earlier this month.
ATPE remains opposed to labeling schools and districts a letter grade of A, B, C, D, or F, because we recognize that doing so only serves to unnecessarily stigmatize the schools and students within them; many other states understand that too and have repealed their previously adopted systems accordingly. However, we recognize that the bills today seek to address problems with the underpinnings of the current accountability system.
ATPE testified on SB 2051 when it was heard in committee last month, and reiterated our input on the language again today. Our suggestions were focused on the addition of a teacher quality measure, inclusion of descriptive language to better communicate what scores under the domains mean, and differentiation between D and F rated schools, which are considered one and the same under current law. ATPE made it clear that a teacher quality measure should not be based on student standardized tests, which would only result in increased reliance on state testing and wouldn’t offer a very holistic picture of a campus or district since the majority of teachers don’t teach STAAR-tested subjects.
ATPE supported language in HB 22 as it made its way through and left the House. We hope much of the work done in that lower chamber will be included in a final bill.
Stay tuned to Teach the Vote for more on action in the Senate Education Committee this busy legislative week.
CONVERSATION
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

09/05/2025
Teach the Vote’s Week in Review: Sept. 5, 2025
A bill aimed at rebranding the STAAR test heads to Gov. Abbott’s desk after contentious debate on the House floor Wednesday night.

09/04/2025
HB 8 heads to governor's desk as second special session comes to a close
The second special session is over, and legislation that will alter Texas' testing and accountability system is headed to the governor's desk.

08/29/2025
Teach the Vote’s Week in Review: Aug. 29, 2025
The STAAR redesign bill awaits its fate, and ATPE shares guidance on SB 12, the Parental Bill of Rights.